A Tale of Two Systems

Here’s something I’ve been struggling with: We live in a time where two systems of political economy have failed: socialism and capitalism.

Socialism has failed a fairly long time ago, and spectacularly so. Capitalism has failed more recently, and there is no consensus on that failing (yet?), but the failure is clearly visible and spreading fast.

Both are, I would argue, 19th century systems of political economy that peaked in the 20th century, but only one imploded with such simultaneity across a large part of the globe that it has — kinda, sorta — a clear end point around 1990. Yes, I know, very broad brush strokes, but bear with me.

For a while, it seemed capitalism had won, especially in the tag team of that time, capitalism + democracy. The End of History, etc. etc.: The long arc of history clearly pointed towards democracy underpinned by a capitalist system. For a generation or two, at least in the richer Western countries, capitalism had generated real wealth and improved quality of life. That’s the story as it’s been told, especially in countries like the US and Germany.

Now, a generation or two later, we see the failure that has crept up on us: An eroded middle class, the first generations in 100 years that will end up poorer than their parents. Less social upward mobility across (at least Western) countries.
Maybe more importantly: The realization that there is no inherent connection between capitalism and democracy. The awakening to the fact that the same system that created wealth for a few short generations (and very unevenly for a small-ish part of the global population) did so at the direct expanse of others, by externalizing costs and internalizing profits: It happened at the expense of the people in poorer countries (globalization, etc.) and the expense of future generations (climate change, etc.): A grab for resources large and small in what amounted to a zero-sum game.

That part of the story — or maybe it’s better called a narrative reframing — is a significant part of what has driven the political ruptures of the last decade or two.

Yet, there doesn’t seem to be much talk of any radically new models, no visions for political economies that function significantly differently?

There are stubs that hint in the right direction, sure: Regenerative approaches, planetary bounds, solar punk. But where’s the bigger vision?

I mean, even just the idea that we might be able to get to an energy surplus via regenerative energy sources should be a central driver of new visions, no?
For the first time in human history, it’s thinkable that humanity might not suffer from energy being scarce: What could we do with essentially infinite energy? What would that unlock, what would a political economy build on a constant energy surplus look like? It would be a whole new paradigm!

Of course that’s not where we are. Instead we see unprecedented concentration of resources, money, political power. Destabilizing culture war. A rise of right wing populists and extremists. A reemergence of the nation state with closed(ish) borders, a remilitarization.

And yet, I’d argue that for all the doom and gloom that we can see out there, there’s a real potential for a positive vision to drive and focus our efforts. There’s a vision out there, certainly, waiting to be formulated and fleshed out, to be brought to life, for people to gather around?